Chung -Shi Duflex Beach black, Men’s Trainers

Jobe Neoprene Surf Booties shoes En Boots

May 27, 2019

Main

Comments Off on Party Leadership Elections are Undemocratic

Originally posted on Medium as Jago Couch Amblers Safety FS661 Black 5Hummel Leather Stadil Vintage Lace-Up Low Junior, Chestnut Brown, EU 32 (Kids 13 UK)on Aug 22, 2015. It’s potentially confusing for me to criticize something as “undemocratic”, which is why I didn’t post it here, but the argument of the post is relevant to my recent posts so I now prefer to have it here to refer to.

We’ve all had our laugh at the Labour party’s leadership election, but it’s time to get serious.

“Internal party democracy” is deeply stupid. You could even say it is undemocratic.

The purpose of a party is to provide a choice — one among several — to voters in public elections.

If every party stands for “whatever its members say”, and each party’s membership is open, then there is no reason to expect the parties to differ from each other. No choice would be provided at the public elections.

Not only at the level of voting, but at the level of support (funding, campaigning), each individual can choose which party, if any, is theirs. But that choice can only be made sensibly if the citizen can tell what a party stands for, and what it is likely to stand for in future. To have value, a party has to stand for something specific and reasonably constant. This goal is not consistent with internal democracy.

The ideal organisational form for a party is for it to be run by a small self-selecting clique. That provides both consistency and the possibility of gradual adaptation to changing circumstances. A fixed constitution is not likely to work, and if it did work would completely freeze the party,Stacy Adams Men's Kordell Cap-Toe Lace-Up OxfordHush Puppies Men's Expert Wt Oxford making it unable to adapt. Any other arrangement (including single-person control) will produce unpredictable changes in position, reducing the value of supporting the party.

Note I’m not arguing against parties having large membership, or against the membership having influence. I am arguing that ordinary potential party members have *greater* influence by being able to join a party with a consistent predictable position, than by having a vote that can be overwhelmed by random motivated entryists. Because membership in a party is and should be voluntary, it is a case where influence should be entirely exerted through the force of “exit”, rather than “voice”. It is better to be a member of a party that is controlled by a small self-selecting clique whose opinions you know and agree with, than to be a member of one which is controlled by a vote of thousands of members, including yourself.

The Labour Party organisation is attempting to be reasonable about choosing which new members should be able to vote, but it is impossible because there is no rationale for allowing any of them to vote at all. If it’s legitimate for a member to change the direction of a party, Joma Indoor LIGA Soccer shoes 5 LIGAW_805 Royal Calcetto ScarpaMens Black Smooth Leather Composite Non Metal Oxford Brogue shoesthen it’s legitimate to join the party in order to change its direction.

This contradiction has been brought to a head by Labour’s introduction of very low subscription fees to join as a voting “supporter”, but charging more is not an absolute defence against hostile entryism. It just postpones things until there’s an election which is close enough, and for high enough stakes to make an attack viable. Of course, the internet makes organising such an attack as easy as creating a Outdoor Mens Walking shoes Sports Beach Breathable Hiking shoes Lightweight Summer shoes, Rubber Sole for Trekking.

Cgoldnel Men's's Mostaza Sport Caballero Brogues Tapiocca vcwwxs719-New Shoes

New Men's Leather Leather Suede Beach shoes Soft Hand-stitched Dual-use Sandals Korean Tide shoes XIAOQI

Skechers Men's Bowerz Olive Black Casual shoes 12 Men US

Things I need to get around to blogging about. Comments welcome.

Cgoldnel Men's's Mostaza Sport Caballero Brogues Tapiocca vcwwxs719-New Shoes

Men's shoes Leatherette Spring Fall Hiking shoes Buckle Split Joint Lace-up Comfort Athletic Casual OutdoorMountaineering Camping Trekking Travel Climbing

It’s a very common trope, on left and right, that the voters are being denied their influence and that democracy is on the decline.

I’m pretty sure the reverse is true: the Western democracies are becoming more democratic as the unprincipled exceptions and institutional arrangements that limited the influence of the voters are eroded.

In particular, the things that are pointed at as undemocratic, such as the attempt to remove Trump, and the failure to execute Brexit, are the second line of defence after democracy has blasted through the barriers that used to exist. Trump could not have made it to the presidential election a decade ago, and though there has always been a majority or close to for leaving the EU, only in 2016 did that become a possibility.

Meta: I’ve decided once again to try to put minor observations on the blog, rather than leaving them in twitter conversations. If you are using a feed reader and liked the old very-low-volume feed, switch to https://blog.anomalyuk.party/category/main/feed and I’ll keep “minis” like this out of the “main” category.

Mens Safety Work Boots Brown Leather Laced Industrial Steel Toe Cap Amblers Men Sports shoes Spring Breathable Lace Up Casual Sneakers Shock Absorbing Slip On Athletic Tennis Walking Trainers

Salabobo QYY-118 New Mens Casual Leather Leisure Comfy Warm Wool High Top Working Boots Black UK Size6

Setting out Xposed Mens Black bluee Genuine Real Leather Classic Lace up Brogue Vintage Style shoes the theory of Bioleninism, I found that we do not have a really precise definition. Spandrell set out the concept and discussion followed between those who “got it”. That means that they at least believed they had identified the essential features from the general description.

In order to broaden the discussion of the concept beyond those who immediately siezed on it, it is necessary to spell out exactly what the essential features are.

My proposed definition

  • Bioleninism describes the practices of an organisation
  • Members are preferentially selected for positions of power if they are members of social subgroups which have natural disadvantages
  • The preferential selection is overt, not covert Hey Dude Farty Funk Chestnut Canvas Mens Slipons shoesNike Unisex Adults' 831945-585 Football Boots
  • The members who are selected for positions of power on this basis are more reliably loyal to the organisation in its existing form than would be the case if they were selected purely on the basis of ability, because they would not expect to achieve similar status if the organisation were to be replaced or reformed.

The last point is Men's Safety shoes Labor Insurance bluee Anti-Slip Summer Breathable Steel Toe Cap Work Men Outdoor Fashion Lightweight of a year ago. Surely an organisation that systematically selected the less able would suffer as a result and fail? The idea is that the extra loyalty that those selected have will compensate the organisation for their lesser effectiveness.

That eerily echoes an argument I put forward in 2012 Men'S Summer Sports Outdoor Sandals Leather Orthopedic Sandals shoes Fisherman Breathable Casual shoes Walking Beach Travel Walk Big SizeTYX-SS Men'S Outdoor Sports shoes Low Cut Casual shoes Korean Fashion Running shoes With Single shoesas a defence of hereditary aristocracy:

The reason for the important people having hereditary peerages is that, when it comes to any kind of power, loyalty is more important than exceptional ability. That’s not to say that incompetence is OK, but if your system of government depends on having people of exceptional ability, then it’s broken. Instead take the most competent people from the pool of those brought up to privilege and loyalty, and if they’re not good enough to, say, run a car company, the solution is not to have a government car company. The Victorian meritocratic civil service was exceptionally effective, but it was a step down the wrong road. The motto of the civil service should be “Good Enough for Government Work” (what’s that in Latin?)

Is aristocratic government then bioleninist? That depends on the part of my proposed definition which remains vague: the “social subgroups which have natural disadvantages”. I left that vague because it has been vague, or treated inconsistently, Wrangler Oxfords-shoes Mens Leather BlackMen's Fashion Flip-flops Personality Outdoor Non-slip Casual Beach Thongin the discussions since November 2017. We won’t have a precise definition of bioleninism until we can pin down the concept of “naturally disadvantaged subgroups” more coherently.

Spandrell started out by describing what made the 20th Century communist regimes internally strong:
When Communism took over Russia and China, those were still very poor, semi-traditional societies. Plenty of semi-starved peasants around. So you could run a Leninist party just on class resentments. “Never forget class-struggle”, Mao liked to say. “Never forget you used to be a serf and you’re not one now thanks to me”, he meant.

In this arrangement, the peasant’s low status is not a natural thing, it is merely a social convention. But because it is such a widespread and long-standing social convention, the peasant can reasonably expect it to return if the regime falls. Therefore loyalty.

Bioleninism, in contrast, occurs in societies where the established norm is meritocracy:
If you live in a free society, and your status is determined by your natural performance; then it follows that to build a cohesive Leninist ruling class you need to recruit those who have natural low-status.+2 Made in Oxfords-shoes Mens Leather blueeMen'S Boots Martin Boots Brock Carved Boots Autumn And Winter Men'S Leather Boots Outdoor Knight Boots Military Boots

The term “Biological Leninism” implies that “natural low status” means actual biological disadvantage, such as womens’ lesser physical strength or some ethnic groups’ lower average intelligence. But there is also mention of “naturally repulsive” groups. Are transexuals really “naturally repulsive”, or is that a social convention? I’m not sure. This seems to be the blurry edge of the definition.

So, let me restate my definition with five points rather than four

  1. Bioleninism describes the practices of an organisation
  2. It depends on a cultural presumption that high ability is a natural qualification for positions of power
  3. Members are preferentially selected for positions of power if they are members of disadvantaged social subgroups, which by (2) means groups of lower average ability
  4. The preferential selection is overt, not covertOudan Espadrilles Men's Casual Canvas shoes Lazy shoes Fisherman's shoes Fashion Comfortable (color Dark bluee, Size 44EU)YC Men's Leather Martin Boots High Tube Boots For Male High Tops Ankle Boots Knight Boots Hiking Camping Desert Training Combat Boots
  5. The members who are selected for positions of power on this basis are more reliably loyal to the organisation in its existing form than would be the case if they were selected purely on the basis of ability, because they would not expect to achieve similar status if the organisation were to be replaced or reformed.

So that takes out feudalism as a bioleninist system, and concentrates it on the modern era where some concept of equality is culturally established. I think that makes it a more useful classification.

Cgoldnel Men's's Mostaza Sport Caballero Brogues Tapiocca vcwwxs719-New Shoes

WLFHM Spring Breathable Loafers Men's England Casual Men's Foot shoes
Nicholas Deakins Moneypit Lightweight Trainers

ZHRUI Men Canvas Boots Fashion High-top Comfortable Sneakers Outdoor Running Hiking Trainers (color Black, Size 9.5 UK)

Responding to the Hey Dude shoes Men's Wally Sox Knit Grey Azur UK11 EU45 is a useful way of clarifying the theory.

The essence of the theory is that a governing structure can gain stability by appointing to high positions members of groups with naturally lower performance, and that that process is advanced in current Western political systems.

“Natural” low performance is an especially controversial concept, but the criticism embraces it: “[women] are not contributing muscle to maintaining law and order to the same extent”

Whether the same applies to, say, homosexual or Punjabi firemen is debatable. I think the identification of sexually omnivorous firemen as the “wrong” kind of homosexual has a lot of merit.

As to Fulton County Sheriffs, a commenter who does not see Bioleninism as a force might well imagine they would “reconsider”, after the incident of a criminal overpowering a small female deputy and killing 3. A believer in the theory of Bioleninism would imagine the opposite. What’s the first link I see when I search “Fulton County Sheriff”? “Asics Hyper MD Running Spikes (UK10)“!  . It’s as if effectiveness on the job is not the dominant factor in appointments…

Emphasising the fact that there are still ethnic and cultural minorities in low-status positions is effectively the inverse of the Puma Men's's Faas 550 Running shoes  : That there is a phenomenon that takes members of some groups and promotes them to positions of power does not imply that it does not leave other members of those groups behind — even a large majority of those members. Bioleninism is a theory about who is selected for positions of power; those not selected can easily remain with the lowest status of all.

The most interesting alternative view is that Bioleninism appears to be happening but is in fact fake: “If women succeed in taking over half the posts in the cabinet… this just means that the cabinet have changed their role to that of national mascots.” Caterpillar Men's Gain Steel Toe orange Work shoesSaucony Men's DXN Trainer VintageWe are looking at Tokenism, not Bioleninism.

Tokenism is absolutely a real phenomenon. It is a different category of phenomenon than Bioleninism, however. Tokenism is in principle an individual motivation. “I am pretending to promote this token person so as to get the reputational benefits of doing so, but I don’t really want to give them any influence”. Bioleninism is an emergent tendency of a political system. A movement which promotes the naturally low-status succeeds because they have loyalty to the system without which they could not possibly achieve the same status. Skechers 52653 BBK Sneaker ManKickers Stsilver Lace, Men's Derby(One of the conditions that gives rise to the phenomenon of Bioleninism is that any rival movement appointing naturally high-status people tends to suffer from problems of lack of loyalty. Other things being equal, it is better to rely on high performers than low performers).

The significance of an emergent tendency, as opposed to an individual motivation, is that nobody needs to believe in or even understand Bioleninism for it to happen. The individual motivations that produce the Bioleninist outcome can be quite unrelated: they can be some theory of Justice, or even be exactly Tokenism. It is a feature of any large movement that pretending to believe something is effectively the same as believing it. The attempt to pretend to believe a thing is what Scott Alexander called “Kolmogorov Complicity”, and he explains why it fails.  . A tight conspiracy of people who trust each other can have a secret agenda and a public agenda. Stanley Hartford Mens Nubuck Leather Material Safety Boots HoneyHush Puppies Belfast, Men's Oxford shoesA movement that has to compete in the public square cannot sustain the distinction for very long. If you claim loudly and dishonestly to believe that it is just to appoint women to cabinet, you will be succeeded within your movement by people who are not in on the joke.

Men's shoes Synthetic Spring Fall Comfort Fashion Boots Light Up shoes Sneakers Black White LED shoes

Onfly Pump Wedge Heels Thick Platform Sandals Ladies Genuine Leather Comfortable Breathable Open Toe Ankel Strap Flower Velcro Closure Mid Heels Sandals Eu Size 35-40